Get the cops out of the media

Neil Basu’s warning was an affront to press freedom.



How did we reach a situation where a top cop thinks he has the right to tell the media what they’re allowed to publish?

This is the case – the alarming case – of the Metropolitan Police’s assistant commissioner for specialist operations, Neil Basu, who caused a storm last week when he warned journalists not to publish Foreign Office leaks.

Seeming to think he lives in North Korea rather the the UK, Basu said journalists who get their hands on leaks pertaining to Kim Darroch should think twice before publishing them.

Darroch was the UK ambassador to the US. He resigned last week following the publication of cables leaked to the journalist Isabel Oakeshott which quoted his less than favourable views on Donald Trump.

Publishing these cables could be a ‘criminal matter’, said Basu. His aim, according to government officials, was to ‘protect the government from embarrassment’.

Since when has it been the police’s role to protect officialdom from journalists who have embarrassing revelations? This really is the stuff of a police state if cops think they must shield Britain’s rulers from the press.

Thankfully there has been pushback against Basu, including from the two Tory leadership contenders and from most of the press. Basu has now backtracked.

But still we have to ask how this shockingly authoritarian idea came out of a policeman’s mouth in a supposedly liberal country.

It isn’t simply down to Basu overreaching. Rather, the Basu affair speaks to the creeping criminalisation of journalism, especially of the dirt-digging variety.

This isn’t even the first time Basu has sought to boss the media about. In March, following the racist massacre of Muslims in New Zealand, he blamed the mainstream media for ‘radicalising’ far-right terrorists and suggested they tone down their rhetoric on certain issues. There was distinctly less pushback against him then, since much of the liberal media agreed with him.

During the Leveson Inquiry into tabloid phone-hacking, Scotland Yard’s Sue Akers arrogantly described tabloid media output as ‘salacious gossip, not what I would describe as being remotely in the public interest’. Maybe the cops should edit the papers?

And of course dozens of journalists have been arrested in recent years as part of the Leveson witch-hunt, and haven’t been found guilty of anything other than trying to get good stories.

For too long, liberals, leftists and others have watched, and even cheered, as the police and the state more broadly have stuck their noses into the press.

The end result is the likes of Basu warning journalists off stories that are clearly in the public interest. To ‘save the government from embarrassment’, no less.

This is where all assaults on press freedom lead – to the protection of the powerful from allegedly grubby journalists. Enough. Get the cops, the government, judges and the state out of the press. The press must be completely free to report and publish the truth as it sees it.

Picture by: Getty.

To enquire about republishing spiked’s content, a right to reply or to request a correction, please contact the managing editor, Viv Regan.


mister wallace

25th July 2019 at 3:58 am

The Police are public servants, not media personalities. Either the Minster of the local authority which controls the Police is the mouth piece. If Mr Plod wants to be a media darling then resign and be a non-public servant.

Stef Steer

15th July 2019 at 11:35 pm

It is interesting just how much the woke establishment (obviously including Basu) have taken to heart the whole darroch leaks thing. In some ways I am heartened, be it hearing pompous asses like malcom rifkind very angrily pontificating on the radio or this authoritarian copper imagining himself in Stalinist Russia. It shows that the civil service is clearly the area of power the establishment will defend at any cost even removing the veil of a functioning Liberal Democracy and bearing the ugly authoritarian underbelly is deemed ok in this case.

I hope we get more leaks because it clearly scares the hell out of them.

James Clow

15th July 2019 at 10:58 pm

“For too long, liberals, leftists and others have watched, and even cheered..”. You say ‘others’. Which others? Who is this mystery group of people who either cannot be politically categorized, or should not be named?

Linda Payne

15th July 2019 at 3:17 pm

The police are using the excuse of the Official secrets act to justify muzzling the press but how the hell could a few rash comments on twitter constitute an offence? To be honest I’m a little sick of the anti trump rhetoric but I’m even sicker at the thought of creeping press censorship

Joe Bloggs

15th July 2019 at 1:02 pm

Disclosure is an offense under the Official Secrets Act.

Does anybody believe that Hunt, Johnson, most of the press etc – members all of the political-media nexus – would be ‘pushing back’ if it had been me, or Joe-nobody-Bloggs down the road who had published that rubbish? It’s BS. Fake news Donald! Fake news!

Eras Bonus-Mus

15th July 2019 at 12:58 pm

Dear Commissioner Basu

Fuck off out of it.

Yours sincerely


Leave a comment

You must be logged in to comment. Log in or Register now.