What Ted Bundy tells us about our therapeutic culture

Criminals and bullies do not suffer from a lack of self-esteem, but a lack of shame.

Nick Xavier Smith

Topics USA

Want unlimited, ad-free access? Become a spiked supporter.

In 1981, Ted Bundy was on death row in America, convicted of the murders of three young women. Before he was executed, he would admit to killing dozens more.

‘Guilt. It’s this mechanism we use to control people’, he told a pair of journalists interviewing him in prison. ‘It’s an illusion. It’s a kind of social control mechanism and it’s very unhealthy. It does terrible things to the body.’

In January 1990, almost one year to the day after Bundy was put to death, the state of California released a report into the root causes of crime. It argued that much of what plagues society boils down to low self-esteem, and insisted on the uplifting idea that, in order to create lasting positive change, people needed to feel better about themselves. ‘Attempting to control people by guilt or shame may achieve temporary goals’, the report read, ‘but it also creates enduring resentment and self-hatred’.

California’s task force is remembered as the peak of a national self-esteem movement that would peter out later in the 1990s. But thanks to the therapeutic culture that had taken root long before and has only grown since, its underlying assumption is largely still taken for granted: that negative feelings are harms to be protected against, rationalised away, or refused entirely.

The curious thing, though, is that many people who feel this way about guilt are only opposed to a very specific kind of guilt. Other kinds – like guilt associated with their country, their race or their wealth – they seem to like very much. Why is that?

Enjoying spiked?

Why not make an instant, one-off donation?

We are funded by you. Thank you!

Please wait...
Thank you!

It helps to start with just how egregiously wrong the self-esteem movement was about one of its central claims: that it’s those with low self-esteem who commit violent crime.

Whether it’s the bully you dealt with on the playground as a kid, or any of the bloodiest movements throughout history, their issue wasn’t their humility or self-doubt. It was their arrogance or the certainty of their righteousness.

Of course, psychopaths like Bundy are the extreme case. They’re a small minority who commit a disproportionate number of violent crimes, and they’re marked by a grossly inflated view of their self-worth and a belief that they’re superior to everyone else.

It’s not that high self-esteem leads someone to violence on its own. Instead, it’s what psychologist Roy Baumeister calls threatened egotism, which is what happens when someone’s high opinion of themselves is challenged. That person can take that criticism, look inward, and consider the fact that they’re not as great as they thought. Or they can choose to preserve their glowing self-evaluation – in which case it’s the other person who must have something wrong with them. ‘He (or she) must be obnoxious, unfair, biased, stupid or unreasonably antagonistic toward you’, Baumeister says. ‘That is how aggression gets started.’

Guilt is what we feel over what we’ve done. Shame is a close cousin – it’s what we feel over what we’ve become. Both send us down the inward-looking route. We feel them not just when we get too in love with ourselves, but when we fail to meet our obligations or fall short of others’ expectations. They’re like nature’s way of putting the brakes on our self-esteem to keep us right with other people.

Though they’re costly for us while we’re experiencing them, guilt and shame can be a benefit to those around us. Traditionally, that has meant our family members, our significant others and the people who rely on us at work. It has also meant the broader public when we break the rules, or anyone, including ourselves, who has to bear the consequences of our poor choices.

When we refuse to acknowledge these negative feelings in ourselves, we tend to blame others. We insist it’s the obligations, expectations, or rules that are placed on us that must have something wrong with them. What’s at fault is really society, institutions, religion or the system, and we are the victims. We get to maintain our self-esteem.

But the feelings don’t just go away. They get transformed into something else, and transferred to the things we hold responsible – our countries, our wealth, our race. This ‘something else’ isn’t quite guilt, because it’s not something you yourself have done. It’s closer to shame, but for something you were born into and can do little about.

While we act upon genuine guilt or shame by changing ourselves, this thing – call it ‘activist remorse’ – insists that we must change the world instead.

Of course, the world often does need changing. The problem starts when changing the world becomes a substitute for changing ourselves.

To proclaim activist remorse for things outside of our control can raise self-esteem – it’s a demonstration to yourself and others that you are, in fact, a good person. The feeling that comes from how we affect people in our daily lives isn’t so pleasant, which is exactly how it helps make us better people.

Activist remorse flips the whole equation on its head: instead of a costly feeling that can be beneficial for others, it’s a good feeling that tends to cost everyone else.

In most of his murders, Ted Bundy would lure unsuspecting women by pretending to be a victim of some accident. He would wear a sling or use crutches and ask them to help carry something to his car, knowing he could guilt them into walking alone with a complete stranger.

Guilt isn’t an illusion. Bundy was wrong about that. But it can be used to control people, and it can be unhealthy.

Psychopaths notwithstanding, most of us want to be good. In a way, guilt and shame do control us. When they come from what we do or fail to do for the people around us, and it’s within our power to make it right, they’re a healthy part of being human.

But there will always be those who exploit these feelings in well-meaning people. Rather than preaching personal responsibility as the way out, they often point to something rotten in society that must be changed before any of us can be good. That might not be healthy, but at least it doesn’t make them feel bad.

Nick Xavier Smith is author of the forthcoming book The Good Guy Problem. Find him on Substack.

Get unlimited access to spiked

You’ve hit your monthly free article limit.

Support spiked and get unlimited access.

Support
or
Already a supporter? Log in now:

Support spiked and get unlimited access

spiked is funded by readers like you. Only 0.1% of regular readers currently support us. If just 1% did, we could grow our team and step up the fight for free speech and democracy.

Become a spiked supporter and enjoy unlimited, ad-free access, bonus content and exclusive events – while helping to keep independent journalism alive.

Monthly support makes the biggest difference. Thank you.

Comments

Want to join the conversation?

Only spiked supporters and patrons, who donate regularly to us, can comment on our articles.

Join today