The EU is unpersonning dissenters

Europeans are being sanctioned, debanked and banned from travel without one iota of due process.

Jacob Reynolds

Topics Free Speech World

Want unlimited, ad-free access? Become a spiked supporter.

On Monday, the EU turned Irish journalist Chay Bowes into a non-person. His assets are now frozen. Anyone in the EU who pays him, employs him, or sends or lends him money risks prosecution. He is banned from travelling to any EU country except Ireland, his country of citizenship. Yet Bowes has not been charged or convicted of any crime, nor has any judge been involved in deciding his fate.

Bowes is a correspondent for RT International (formerly Russia Today). He was sanctioned for ‘information manipulation and dissemination of narratives that legitimise and sustain the ongoing Russian war of aggression against Ukraine’. Judging by his videos, Bowes seems to genuinely believe his role is to provide an alternative to the EU’s supposed ‘lies’ about Russia (where he lives) and Ukraine. Whether he is right or wrong is beside the point – in a free society, nothing one says ought to be grounds for unpersoning.

Bowes may well be a Russian propagandist, a misguided crank and a conspiracy theorist. But whatever your opinion of him, free speech does not mean much if it only applies to those we like.

Hüseyin Doğru is another victim of the EU’s draconian use of sanctions. The journalist, who founded red.media, was blacklisted by the EU last year for ‘systematically spreading false information about politically controversial topics, with the intention of sowing ethnic, political and religious discord among his predominantly German-speaking audience’.

Doğru, it appears, has all the typical prejudices of the anti-Israel set, and the EU also accuses his outlet of spreading Hamas narratives. For these speech crimes, he, his wife and his three young children must live on €506 a month of his own money. His wife’s accounts have also been frozen.

The EU’s sanctions regime imposes life-altering consequences on individuals, but is not beholden to normal criminal procedure. It is effectively a bureaucratic punishment, imposed independently of any recognised legal system. And because the powers are effectively extrajudicial, there is no good remedy for those affected. Clearly, someone who has had his bank accounts frozen cannot afford the cost of a legal challenge.

Enjoying spiked?

Why not make an instant, one-off donation?

We are funded by you. Thank you!

Please wait...
Thank you!

It might be hard for many to find much to sympathise with when it comes to Hamas apologists and Russian propagandists, but it is the principle that matters here. These powers are not only unprecedented and accompanied by the flimsiest of legal or democratic safeguards – they are also part of a disturbing trend that could lead almost anyone to get caught up in them.

The sanctions are aimed at those who are ‘supporting or otherwise facilitating the use of coordinated information manipulation and interference’. But this is a bucket that anyone critical of the EU could fall into – at least according to European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen. In her State of the Union address in September, von der Leyen lumped ‘the ultranationalists or the anti-Europeans’ (ie, Eurosceptic populist parties) together with ‘Russian interference or disinformation’. ‘The names may be different, but their goal is the same’, she said. The direction of travel, boosted by EU initiatives like the ‘Democracy Shield’, means that anyone who objects to the Brussels consensus could soon be put into the same category as Russian propagandists.

No one denies that our adversaries, whether Russia or Hamas, aim to sow discord, spread misinformation and undermine our democracies. But the greatest gift these enemies could ever receive is the sight of EU citizens being sanctioned for mere speech crimes. The EU seems determined to demonstrate that it is an enemy of European democracy.

Jacob Reynolds is policy director at Freedom and Sovereignty Initiative Europe. Follow him on X: @jacobreynolds

Get unlimited access to spiked

You’ve hit your monthly free article limit.

Support spiked and get unlimited access.

Support
or
Already a supporter? Log in now:

spiked is even better on the app

Read, watch and listen to spiked wherever you are. Our brand-new app brings everything together, with ad-free reading, audio articles and offline access.

Become a spiked supporter to unlock exclusive app access, unlimited articles, bonus podcasts, discounts and special events.

Monthly support makes the biggest difference. Thank you.

Comments

Want to join the conversation?

Only spiked supporters and patrons, who donate regularly to us, can comment on our articles.

Join today