In defence of age-gap relationships

Don’t let the Russell Brand and David Walliams scandals usher in a new age of puritanism.

Ella Whelan

Ella Whelan
Columnist

Topics Feminism UK

Want unlimited, ad-free access? Become a spiked supporter.

The conviction of Russell Brand as a rapist and sexual assailant has embarrassed many in politics. The once-popular TV and radio personality-turned-leftie politico was, at one point, the go-to man for politicians who wanted to get down with pop culture. UK foreign secretary Ed Miliband has delivered a grovelling apology to explain why he went on Brand’s show back in 2015, against the advice of top Labour MPs.

With all this in mind, Labour seems to have spent the weekend scrabbling for something to atone for its regrettable dalliances with Brand. And it has found a dead cat to throw on the table: making relationships between young women and older men illegal. In an interview on the BBC’s Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg, work and pensions secretary Pat McFadden entertained this idea in response to what he called the ‘abuse of power by powerful men’.

Mia Latter, who alleges that she was raped by Brand when she was 16 and he was 30, wants to make it illegal for people in their ‘30s, 40s and 50s’ to have sex with those under the age of 18. In response to a question about this campaign, McFadden confirmed that it would be discussed by the government, claiming that the Brand conviction had put changing the age of consent ‘up in lights’.

Following the allegations made against David Walliams (many of which involve very young women, including one allegedly under the age of consent), some in government have also expressed interest in suggestions from groups like Close the Consent Gap, which wants a staggered age of consent. This would mean that it would be illegal for anyone over 19 to have sex with a 16-year-old, and illegal for anyone over 20 to have sex with a 17-year-old.

There has long been criticism of famous men shunning their own peer group for younger models – Leonardo DiCaprio gets a free pass for his distaste for anyone over the age of 25 because he remains a heartthrob. The news that 83-year-old Al Pacino welcomed a baby with his then 29-year-old girlfriend, Noor Alfallah, in 2023 made eyes roll across the globe. While there is a great difference between young girls in their late teens and young women in their late 20s, it’s hardly breaking news that famous men like to prolong their sense of youth by proving that they can still charm women more than half their age.

Enjoying spiked?

Why not make an instant, one-off donation?

We are funded by you. Thank you!

Please wait...
Thank you!

The difference between Brand and other celebrities was that some of his relationships with young women were abusive. The problem was not the age gap, but the fact that Brand was intent on getting sex from women at any age and, at times, at any cost.

We should always be nervous about the state trying to further regulate sexual relations – especially under the guise of protecting us. At the ripe old age of 34, with a young daughter myself, I occasionally wince at the relationships I had during my late teens and early 20s with older men. But, at 17, the boys our age were completely uninteresting to us – they were often physically and emotionally immature (or so we thought). Therefore, seeking the attention and attraction of someone a little older was usually the goal on nights out.

To insist that all young women are always doomed to be harmed by the power dynamic present in age-gap relationships is to deny them any agency. While most of us might at the very least raise an eyebrow at the reasons why a man in his 40s might be chasing 21-year-olds, the idea that the state should define an ‘acceptable’ age gap is more worrying than a few men going through a midlife crisis.

Politicians have form when it comes to knee-jerk reactions to serious events. In the wake of the murder of Sarah Everard in 2021, some called for night-time curfews for men and tracking apps. Such suggestions were both illiberal and pointless when it came to fears about women’s safety.

Just because Brand abused his power doesn’t mean we should go on a crusade against young women’s sexual freedom. Where possible and reasonable, young people need the space to experiment, make mistakes and figure out their own parameters – including in the world of sex and relationships. Raising the age of consent out of concerns over power dynamics between older males and younger females sends a message to young women that they are too vulnerable to make their own decisions – a characterisation that doesn’t reflect the reality of the many terrifyingly confident teenage girls I’ve met.

As adults, we should instil moral standards and advise young people about what we hope they do and don’t get up to. I can’t be the only one who doesn’t need a trial to convince me that someone like Walliams is a wrong ’un. But to invite the state to police young women’s sexual freedoms and choices is to return to an earlier, more illiberal era, in which ‘protection’ meant the stifling of women’s agency. If we allow a moral panic about grooming and consent to distract us from the clear failings of media institutions and their fawning over creeps like Brand, we will throw all women under the bus.

Ella Whelan is a spiked columnist and the author of What Women Want: Fun, Freedom and an End to Feminism.

Get unlimited access to spiked

You’ve hit your monthly free article limit.

Support spiked and get unlimited access.

Support
or
Already a supporter? Log in now:

Support spiked and get unlimited access

spiked is funded by readers like you. Only 0.1% of regular readers currently support us. If just 1% did, we could grow our team and step up the fight for free speech and democracy.

Become a spiked supporter and enjoy unlimited, ad-free access, bonus content and exclusive events – while helping to keep independent journalism alive.

Monthly support makes the biggest difference. Thank you.

Comments

Want to join the conversation?

Only spiked supporters and patrons, who donate regularly to us, can comment on our articles.

Join today