As an ITU doctor, I cannot clap for the NHS

Frontline staff deserve respect. But the NHS bureaucracies are unaccountable, incompetent and exploitative.

Michael Lucas

Topics Politics UK

The coronavirus outbreak has completely upended our hospitals. Makeshift ITUs have been created in areas completely unsuited for critically ill patients. Our regular capacity to move freely between wards, and to carry phones, drugs and equipment, has all been lost to the need to wear full PPE. I have worked alongside dedicated nurses looking after the sickest of the sick in this crisis, and in those early weeks I formed a real sense of camaraderie with my colleagues. Yet despite being embedded in the frontline, I cannot bring myself to clap for the NHS.

I understand why people want to show solidarity with frontline workers, especially when the lockdown deprives the public of the chance to make a meaningful contribution to the crisis. I can’t clap for the NHS because of a truth that all NHS staff come to learn – that the NHS runs only by exploiting its workers.

This is not a problem new to the Covid era. All frontline workers have become used to routine assaults by hospital managers. Up and down the country, healthcare professionals find our recorded hours of work are massaged into smaller and smaller figures. We are having to fund more and more of our equipment and training out of our own pockets. We pay excessive parking fees for the privilege of parking on available grass verges. If we are too tired to drive home, we pay to stay in accommodation that can lack heating, hot water and even electricity. Many doctors would be grateful to have so much as a coat hook, let alone somewhere secure to prevent their belongings from being stolen.

But it isn’t just this baseline neglect that disenfranchises us frontline staff. Our ability to deliver care is constantly hampered by poor organisation. Antiquated bleep systems are still used to communicate with one another, and the ability of our bosses to coordinate our complex rotas is questionable at best. Perhaps worst of all is the drive to digitise as much of our work as possible, while the necessary resources to carry out this work are withheld. I cannot emphasise enough how frustrating it is to know that crucial investigations for an acutely deteriorating patient are technically available on the system, but that I won’t be able to access them for at least 15 minutes.

I doubt anything written so far would even raise the eyebrow of an NHS worker. The NHS holds effective monopsony power, and we all grow desensitised to the farcical situations we encounter throughout our working lives. The farce has been harder to ignore, however, since Covid broke out.

Some doctors, such as Max Pemberton, noticed that with the bulk of managerial staff out of the way, his trust has been capable of making agile and drastic changes. Having spoken with friends and colleagues, the same cannot be said for much of the country. When the crisis was at its worst, and we were stretched to dangerous ratios of patients to staff, you would hope that every second of our time was spent looking after the patients. But again, much of the infrastructure is left to the frontline to fix, be it setting up printers or fixing sluices. In many hospitals where staff are wearing full PPE in cramped, make-do conditions, they get further baked by the hospital central-heating systems, over which they have no control.

The disconnect between frontline staff and management is enormous. Management can make mistakes, whether it is purchasing the wrong equipment or delivering faulty IT systems, with complete impunity, while those of us who try to pick up the pieces of their mess get dragged through tribunals and the courts (such as Dr Bawa-Garba).

This unaccountability is not limited to hospital management. The failures of procurement departments and of Public Health England during this crisis are by now well-documented. As for how much time and money is wasted by countless other NHS bodies – including (but not limited to) NHS Digital, NHS Resolution and NHS Business Services Authority – I can only guess. No one seems interested in holding these bodies to account, either.

No clearer example of this can be found than Dr Chris Day, who blew the whistle on a situation that put his patients in tremendous danger. Because of this, he has been attacked relentlessly by his NHS Trust, NHS England and even civil servants within the Department of Health. Day’s landmark case in the Court of Appeal defended whistleblowing protection for junior doctors. His fight against the NHS establishment has achieved more than the British Medical Association – the doctors’ trade union – has achieved in years of supine negotiations (the fact the BMA abandoned him to face the fight alone is telling). Ultimately, creatures of the NHS establishment have shown themselves happy to oppose those defending patient safety in order to promote the status of their organisation over its responsibility to deliver care.

If you must still clap for the NHS, don’t let the work of doctors, nurses, physios and pharmacists whitewash the actions of the sprawling NHS bureaucracies. Perhaps a clap with three fingers to the palm is a clap for the front line, without extending it to those hiding behind us.

Michael Lucas is the pseudonym of an NHS intensive-care doctor.

Help spiked prick the Covid consensus

So here we are – 15 weeks into Britain’s three-week lockdown. We hope you are all staying sane out there, and that spiked has been of some assistance in that. We have ramped up our output of late, to provide a challenge to the Covid consensus. But we couldn’t have done that without your support. spiked – unlike so many things these days – is completely free. We rely on our loyal readers to fund our journalism. So if you enjoy our work, please do consider becoming a regular donor. Even £5 per month can be a huge help. You can donate here.Thank you! And stay well.

Donate now

To enquire about republishing spiked’s content, a right to reply or to request a correction, please contact the managing editor, Viv Regan.


K Tojo

26th May 2020 at 4:53 pm

I don’t know if we are allowed to recommend books on this forum but I would suggest that anyone interested in an insider’s analysis of the failings of “our NHS” would do well to read “The NHS is Not Working by Dr Hamid Sarwar.

He explains in detail why that money-wasting and outdated socialist project is a very long way from being the envy of the world. Germany, Holland and even France offer far better alternatives.

Eric Praline

26th May 2020 at 6:21 pm

What is socialist about it?

Marvin Jones

2nd June 2020 at 12:09 pm

Dr Meirion Thomas, a senior consultant in the NHS, now gone private wrote an article in the Daily Mail a couple of years ago, and I am sure he has written a book on this very topic. I have had the unfortunate genes to have been in hospitals for several reasons since turning 60, until then, a pretty fit chap pretty good at almost all ball games. For many hours, unable to get off my back, I began to enjoy people watching, listening and observing all activities of staff mainly. Half the staff do work hard and appear to often, be brilliant, but carry the other half who ONLY look forward to the end of the month.

Warren Alexander

26th May 2020 at 3:33 pm

You only have to look back at the scandal in the Mid Staffs hospital to see quite how bad the NHS can be, despite assurances that it is the ‘best health service in the world’. Unless and until politicians are prepared to publicity acknowledge the truth about serious failing throughout the NHS clinical and managerial staff, we will continue to pump in billions as a sacrificial offering to a sacred cow.

Linda Payne

27th May 2020 at 5:49 pm

Your right and I wonder what will happen to Saint Tom’s money, 30 million of it. You wont here of where it goes because the NHS swallows any money its given and things just get worse. Mental health is practically run by the Charity sector now and vulnerable people are suffering as a result as the charity workers resent the benefits these ill people get. Expect more ‘services’ to be run by charity, care and treatment on the cheap while middle class management continue to sit pretty on 5 and 6 figure salaries

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to comment. Log in or Register now.