The hilarious breakdown of the Islamo-left alliance

With growing tensions between socially conservative Muslims and progressive liberals, what is the future of their traditional alliance on the British left? If events of the past week are anything to go by, the answer appears to be that there isn’t one.

This uneasy marriage got a reality check last week when a Green Party councillor and practising Muslim, Mothin Ali, appeared reluctant to sign a set of ‘pledges’ on behalf of the LGBTQIA+ Greens, Feminist Greens and other similar groups. The MP for Blackburn, ‘Gaza Independent’ Adnan Hussain, then waded into the debate. ‘It’s no secret that Muslims tend to be socially conservative’, Hussain said. ‘Is there a space on the left to create a broad enough church to allow Muslims an authentic space, just as it does other minority groups?’

A lot rests on the answer to this question, at least for the electoral prospects of the Green Party. In recent years, its vote has been bolstered by Muslims, particularly young Muslims, who share the party’s views on economics and Palestine. In the darker and more ideologically dogmatic sections of this Muslim-Green alliance, anti-Jewish sentiment and anti-Semitic conspiracy theories have taken root, too. A Times investigation last year found that around 20 prospective Green candidates at the last General Election had made disturbing statements about Israel, Hamas and the 7 October attacks.

The problem is that the two camps were never remotely aligned on other key issues. These include rights and protections for sexual minorities (such as same-sex marriage), the degree to which queer rights and queer theory should be taught in school, and the sanctity of life – both in terms of abortion and assisted dying. It is no secret that British Muslims are more conservative on these issues compared even with the general population, let alone the progressive left.

The British left could have seen these problems coming a mile off by looking across the Atlantic. That this relationship is fundamentally unstable was made clear in November when Donald Trump was re-elected. Michigan – home to America’s largest Muslim population and its only Muslim-majority city, Hamtramck – voted Republican. Exit polls recorded a surge in support for Trump among Muslims in the state. This came after Hamtramck’s city council – which is also majority Muslim – voted to ban the flying of Pride flags on city property in 2023.

For some time, the Democratic Party had complacently assumed that rising racial and religious diversity in America would play in its favour. But this theory of ‘demographic destiny’ has proved to be hugely flawed. Unsurprisingly, many Muslim voters found themselves much closer aligned with Republicans on issues such as gay marriage, abortion, euthanasia and trans rights.

Now, it seems that this divorce is about to happen in Britain. Socially conservative British Muslims should not expect progressive liberals to appease them. Nor should they be expected to sacrifice their values, rooted in their faith and cultural heritage, just to please the left.

Political marriages of convenience like this are a recipe for inept governance and confused priorities. The left and British Muslims were never natural allies – and both sides must now face up to this fact.

Rakib Ehsan is the author of Beyond Grievance: What the Left Gets Wrong about Ethnic Minorities, which is available to order on Amazon.