School closures are punishing working mothers

The decision not to reopen UK primary schools for all classes will hit women hardest.

Tessa Mayes Clarke

Topics Feminism UK

So, after weeks of pressure from teachers’ unions and the media, all warning of the dangers of sending kids back to school, the UK government has caved in. It has now dropped its plan to get all children back in primary schools before the summer.

This decision will be especially tough on mothers, who, since the lockdown began in March, have been consigned to the home.

Not that you would know this from the social-media-led image of lockdown life. There you will find countless photographs showing women and men working from home in joyous, child-rearing harmony.

Yet the truth is that women still bear much of the responsibility for childcare. According to the Office for National Statistics, even before the lockdown three in 10 working mothers (28.5 per cent) said they had reduced their working hours to help with childcare over the past year, compared with only one in 20 working fathers (4.8 per cent). The lockdown has exacerbated this inequality. Indeed, the Institute for Fiscal Studies reports that more mothers than fathers are likely to have left paid work during lockdown.

And now, as the nation’s working life slowly resumes, it is doing so with fewer women able to take part. Instead, they are consigned, thanks to school closures, to childcare duty, from providing their children with meals to supervising their education.

The recent plan to allow two households to merge into ‘support bubbles’, if one of them contains just one adult, might seem like good news. It will allow single parents to team up and help each other, especially if, in the government’s words, he or she is feeling ‘particularly lonely’.

Yet working parents need their time fully liberated, not half liberated. To stress the mental-health cost of being ‘cut off from family and friends’, as the UK prime minister Boris Johnson put it, misses the point for working women, especially single mothers. We don’t need the government to tell us that our relationships with family and friends are important. We know that. What we really need is the freedom to work, not to enjoy a hug. And for that to happen, we need to be able to send our children to school.

Of course, women need the freedom to be mothers. But we also need the freedom to work if we want and need to. The government and the unions know this, hence they frequently champion women’s equality in the workplace. Yet when it comes to opening schools right now, both the government and unions are acting like Victorian patriarchs, effectively forcing mothers to stay at home and look after the children.

The decision to postpone a full reopening of schools till after the summer smacks of a lack of imagination on the part of our leaders. After all, the problems posed by Covid-19 are hardly insurmountable. The infection rate remains low; children are not especially susceptible to the virus; and their chances of becoming seriously ill are vanishingly small. It is surely not beyond the wit of man or woman to increase school space and resources so as to allow all classes to be sent back to school.

Indeed, many parents have already been showing the imagination and will that our government, unions and schools seem to lack. On social media, for instance, parents have been suggesting using church halls, unused accommodation, tents and so on, as ways to overcome the shortage of school space. Parents have also been helping each other with their children’s education, swapping curriculum notes and videos of different schools’ online teaching provisions.

Yet for all that, it is imperative that our elected leaders start to show some actual leadership, rather than seeming constantly behind the curve, or flailing in the face of public criticism.

Because, as it stands, they are doing women in particular a grave disservice. They are depriving us of what we have come rightly to expect as ours: the right to be able to work, as equals, alongside men. So let’s not go backwards. In a modern society, women’s equality is far too important to be undermined by fear and a lack of leadership and imagination.

Tessa Mayes Clarke is a journalist, author and working parent.

Picture by: Getty.

Help spiked prick the Covid consensus

So here we are – 15 weeks into Britain’s three-week lockdown. We hope you are all staying sane out there, and that spiked has been of some assistance in that. We have ramped up our output of late, to provide a challenge to the Covid consensus. But we couldn’t have done that without your support. spiked – unlike so many things these days – is completely free. We rely on our loyal readers to fund our journalism. So if you enjoy our work, please do consider becoming a regular donor. Even £5 per month can be a huge help. You can donate here.Thank you! And stay well.

Donate now

To enquire about republishing spiked’s content, a right to reply or to request a correction, please contact the managing editor, Viv Regan.


Steve Stevens

24th June 2020 at 11:19 pm

The author seems to miss important points. Schools and childcare are not the same thing. How many jobs fit within 8:45 and 3pm? Schools are normally open 36 weeks of the year, not 52.
Both my wife and I work less than 40 hours a week each, but working irregular shifts means we still rely on family to look after kids in the holidays.
Academics and journalists might have the needs of the working class in their thoughts but the problem is much bigger than this article describes. Working families need good quality, affordable childcare as the option to rely on elderly relatives is greatly reduced in these cautious times (and that’s leaving aside the rights and wrongs of relying on the elderly to look after their grandchildren).


24th June 2020 at 3:44 pm

Schools are there to provide a child minding service ( I don’t think many people can have a high regard for the education provided-how far down the list are we on literacy , numeracy etc ? Even Any Answers R4 ( usually quite a pro-guardian type of programme) was full of disgruntled middle-class women whose children had had no teaching or contact with their schools for months. In America a lot of parents have decided to home school -wonder if there will be a similar change in Britain?

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to comment. Log in or Register now.