Extinction Rebellion is an extremist group

This green group is nuts. But that doesn't mean it should be included on any police lists.

Brendan O'Neill

Brendan O'Neill

Topics Politics UK

The hissy fit over the inclusion of Extinction Rebellion on a police list of ‘extremist ideologies’ is hilarious. It is so obviously a case of protesting too much. ‘How dare you call us extremists!’, cry the leaders of this movement that says billions of people will die as a result of climate change and that the only way to stop this calamity is by putting a halt on modernity and forcing human beings to live in wigwams on a diet of nuts and seeds. Sorry, guys, but you can’t go around preaching that the end is nigh like a medieval self-flagellating cult and then moan about being called bonkers. If it walks like a nutter and quacks like a nutter, it’s probably a nutter.

This is the news that XR – last seen marching through London and warning its inhabitants that their use of motorcars and consumption of meat would cause billions of people to die – has been included in a coppers’ report about extremist activism. The report, collated by Counter Terrorism Policing South East, is designed to ‘[safeguard] young people and adults from ideological extremists’. Those ideological extremists include far-right groups like National Action, a couple of mad Islamist outfits, right-wing identitarian loons like Generation Identity, and Extinction Rebellion. Guess which listing has sent the chattering classes into meltdown? Yep, XR’s, which right-on types have described as an offence against good sense and liberty. Home secretary Priti Patel’s partial defence of the inclusion of XR in the list of extremists has further inflamed the debate. ‘How dare she!’, greens cry, echoing the messianic leader of their crazed death cult, Greta Thunberg.

There are two things to say about this controversy. The first is that the cops should not be drawing up lists like this at all. Police should only interfere with groups that have carried out violent acts or which are plotting to carry out violent acts. Every other political group should be left completely and utterly alone. They should not be monitored. They should be free to associate. And they should be free to march in public. That goes for the racist dweebs in Generation Identity, the Islamist hotheads in myopically anti-Western Islamo-groups, and the green hysterics of Extinction Rebellion. Freedom demands that these groups be allowed to organise and talk shit as they see fit. They should only be interfered with if there is a solid suspicion that they are crossing the line from agitation to violent action.

Strikingly, though, the hip pretend-liberals of the pro-XR lobby aren’t kicking up a fuss about the inclusion of, say, Generation Identity in this list of extremists. Even though Generation Identity has also not done anything terroristic. If you were a consistent liberal, someone who believed that every organisation and individual has the right to express themselves publicly and to protest publicly – as spiked believes – then you would be as outraged by GI’s inclusion on this McCarthyite list as you are by XR’s. But clearly, this isn’t about the principle of liberty – it’s about protecting the loons of the green cult from any kind of criticism or ridicule.

But here’s the thing: XR is extremist. It’s about as extremist as it gets. It is a deranged, classist, authoritarian outfit that chants and sings about the end of the world and which lies – openly – about billions dying from climate change. It is anti-modern, anti-progress and anti-human. Its members dress in red and mope through the streets while wailing about meat-eating and industry. It depicts mankind as a plague on the planet and calls for the kinds of restrictions on modern life that would plunge vast swathes of society into darkness and penury. It is against industrialisation, against meaningful development and against comfort. These are extremist ideas.

Should it be watched and censured by the state? Absolutely not. Let the loons do whatever they want to do. Back off, cops. You too, Priti. But are they mental? Yes, they are. Totally mental.

Brendan O’Neill is editor of spiked and host of the spiked podcast, The Brendan O’Neill Show. Subscribe to the podcast here. And find Brendan on Instagram: @burntoakboy

Picture by: Getty.

To enquire about republishing spiked’s content, a right to reply or to request a correction, please contact the managing editor, Viv Regan.


botalap botalap

21st January 2020 at 4:33 pm

Make $125 per hour with your phone or laptop from …..www.mywork5.com

Mark Houghton

15th January 2020 at 5:02 pm

Any group should be allowed to exist regardless of their ideology, extremist (however that’s define and by who) but their members should be punished if they break the law of the land.

Ecgbert King

15th January 2020 at 11:30 am

XR are just the new Western version of the Khmer Rouge seeking to establish a Year Zero agrarian society, with no science, no intellectuals and advancement – and an awful lot of death and oppression.

Graham Woodford

14th January 2020 at 7:48 pm

Is this even journalism, characterising people whose fundamental principals are supported overwhelmingly by the scientific community, and scientific evidence, as nutters? In continuing to gaslight one of the leading characters in that movement? ‘Messianic leader of a death cult’. Now where have I heard that before.

Continue to do your ostrich act. In the meantime, try to do better to support your argument than by self-reverentially linking articles by other ‘spiked’ writers, who mysteriously, while claiming to be a free thinking happy band seem to represent a bit of cult themselves, if the remarkable similarity of views is anything to go by. Anyway, you can try, but you won’t find any scientific evidence to support your views that there is nothing of any concern, and something will turn up. Because there isn’t any.

Jerry Owen

14th January 2020 at 9:23 pm

I’ve asked you before .. give us the science in your own words?

Kojak Kojak

15th January 2020 at 5:42 am

Yes it is journalism & bloody good & accurate journalism at that.

Graham Townsend

14th January 2020 at 7:13 pm

Every national science academy around the developed world has assessed the evidence for anthropogenic climate disruption, and issued statements endorsing the science.
I have a list of around 300 selected references to peer-reviewed research on climate change and it makes sobering reading.
We have clear warnings about the economic consequences of inaction from the Bank of England, Reserve Bank of Australia, The World Bank, IMF, the OECD, the global reinsurance industry and, increasingly, from major investment advisors.
We have warnings from NATO and (dammit) the Pentagon about the consequences for regional insecurity and mass migration.
Yet we still have this cargo-cult that promotes endless GDP growth, in defiance of the laws of physics – effectively a belief in perpetual motion.
We still have people choosing to sneer at protesters who actually give a damn about their kids’ future.
How selfish, how deliberately blind, how childish. How contemptible.

Graham Woodford

14th January 2020 at 7:49 pm


Jerry Owen

14th January 2020 at 9:24 pm

Your science in your own words please?

Graham Woodford

15th January 2020 at 10:44 am

I’m not sure what spurious point you are trying to make. I’m not a scientist. Neither is The author of this piece or any other of the Spiked ‘journalists’ and their colleagues elsewhere claiming to expose the myth of climate change. Are you, and what is your incontrovertible evidence otherwise?

Jerry Owen

16th January 2020 at 7:49 am

Graham Woodford.
As I thought.. as per usual a long winded post with no science.

Jerry Owen

16th January 2020 at 10:07 pm

Graham Woodford
Is Chris Packam a scientist ? Is David Attenborough a scientist ?
No they aren’t so therefore you can out your case can’t you .. or are you frit ?

Jerry Owen

16th January 2020 at 2:55 pm

‘300 selected references’ .. whoopy doo for you !
There are more scientists that do not believe in AGW.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to comment. Log in or Register now.