The banality of Labour anti-Semitism

Corbyn has helped bring Jew-hatred back into the political mainstream.

Liam Thompson

Share
Topics Politics UK

In normal circumstances, General Elections are fought on matters of policy and ideology. These, however, are far from normal circumstances. This General Election presents us with a moral as well as a political test. Brexit may feel like the central issue before us. But historians of the future may also judge this to be the year that anti-Semitism returned to the British political mainstream.

Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn is either himself anti-Semitic or so blind to anti-Semitism that he has allowed it to flourish in the party on his watch. Either way, Labour’s problem with Jew hatred is now beyond dispute. Labour has legitimised explicitly anti-Semitic Islamist groups, it has tolerated anti-Semitic behaviour within its ranks, and Corbyn himself has been happy to ramble on about ‘British Zionists’ having ‘no sense of English irony’. This has led Labour to the ignominy of a probe into its anti-Semitism, led by the Equalities and Human Rights Commission.

Until recently, Islamist groups and other propagators of anti-Semitism were on the fringes of public life. But they have been boosted by Corbyn’s Labour – a party that is now within touching distance of power. For those in the wider Labour Party who don’t harbour anti-Semitic sentiments, the General Election poses a significant moral question: is the mainstreaming of anti-Semitism a price worth paying for gaining political power?

For Labour MPs and activists, unfortunately, it seems it is. As former Tory special adviser Nick Timothy has argued, Labour MPs who claim to be anti-racist, while simultaneously campaigning to make Corbyn prime minister, are engaged in rank hypocrisy. Right-minded people watch with increasing disbelief as Labour campaigns to install as prime minister a man who has appeared on an Iranian state-funded TV station and spread conspiracy theories about Israel.

Even Tony Blair, who has long criticised Corbyn and his Momentum support base, has stated he will still vote for Labour. This is despite the fact that, as he acknowledges, anti-Semitism is ‘absolutely killing Labour’. One wonders just how much anti-Semitism Blair would be willing to tolerate before withdrawing his support for Corbyn.

What is clear is that, beyond some notable exceptions, such as former MP John Mann, the Labour tribe has made its choice: anti-Semitism is a price worth paying for power.

In Eichmann in Jerusalem (1963), Hannah Arendt asked the painful question of how the Holocaust was even allowed to happen. Were the majority of Germans, and perhaps Europeans, so virulently anti-Semitic that they actually endorsed it?

She concluded that, no, most people were not anti-Semitic. Rather, they were blinded to immorality by its normalisation. So, while they may not actively have endorsed the Holocaust, they passively endorsed it through their inaction. This is what she described as the ‘banality of evil’.

Similarly, the Parliamentary Labour Party, which is unwilling to challenge Corbyn and his cronies, is in effect endorsing the anti-Semitism in Labour’s midst. Labour’s anti-Semitism has become banal. MPs and activists have put aside moral concerns in order to achieve political goals. In so doing they are allowing for the normalisation of anti-Semitic ideas.

They will be forever tarnished by this, politically and personally. And with Labour lost, the moral challenge falls to others.

To her credit, Liberal Democrat leader Jo Swinson yesterday ‘categorically’ ruled out putting Jeremy Corbyn into No10 via a coalition or other agreement. Let’s hope she honours this pledge, if and when it is tested. And let’s hope others follow suit.

If we wake up to a hung parliament on 13 December, the question of whether to work with Corbyn will be forced on to the Lib Dems again, along with other potential coalition partners like the Scottish National Party. The temptation to form a government with Labour that could offer what each prospective partner wants, from a second EU referendum to a Scottish independence referendum, would be great. But decent politicians should reject this temptation.

SNP leader Nicola Sturgeon has indicated that she could support a Corbyn government. We can only hope that the millions of people around the country who are appalled by what they see happening on the far left hold the SNP accountable for this potential moral failure.

These will be an anxious five weeks for Britain’s Jewish community. It is in the power of leaders of all political stripes to alleviate this anxiety by condemning anti-Semitism and refusing to work with those who perpetuate it. This is no longer just Labour’s problem. Until we can categorically say that Jeremy Corbyn will never be prime minister, it is all of our problem.

Liam Thompson is a writer.

Picture by: Getty

To enquire about republishing spiked’s content, a right to reply or to request a correction, please contact the managing editor, Viv Regan.

Comments

L Whiting

8th November 2019 at 11:14 pm

Labour Party anti-Semitic? That is Zionist fake news from the Board of Deputies of Jews. I think the Labour Party is a disaster just like you. They do not represent all Jews, like me who has Sephardic ancestry. Sephardic Jews had 500 years of being burnt alive in market squares by the Catholic Inquisition and so did Muslims in Spain. There may be elements within the Labour party that are anti-Semitic but they are everywhere even among Conservatives and Jews. Anti-Semitism and Islamaphobia are from the same Alf Garnet roots. One should always call a spade a spade and not be servile to fake news.
The Israeli Army attacks Palestinians who themselves are of Hebrew origin. So, Israel is anti-Semitic. Read academic DNA research about Palestinians and Jews. Israel arrests children for stone-throwing every child does. They strip young children and imprison them, they terrorise families by breaking into their houses at night and beating them up. Israel has a naive paranoid population created by fake propaganda and news. It was a Jewish psychologist who said persons from concentration camps often imitate the abuse they receive and exercise it on other people later. The treatment of meted out by the US on prisoners such as in Abu Grade prison as a result of techniques taught by an Israeli Company. Get real. Being Jewish is not a universal identity any more than being a Christian or a Muslim. People come in all colours shapes and races.

Hugh Roper

7th November 2019 at 6:32 pm

May I echo the comment of Jim Lawrie (6 Nov, 9.51am). Liam Thompson trivializes the Nazi Holocaust by his absurd comparisons with the modern Labour Party. Spiked should be ashamed at publishing such vicious drivel.

Winston Stanley

6th November 2019 at 11:42 am

It is fine to destabilise and to wage wars on Muslim countries but not to even criticise I srael. The British state is a Zionist state and it needs to fall.

Ven Oods

6th November 2019 at 4:20 pm

It is fine to destabilise and to wage wars on Muslim countries but not to even criticise I srael.

You know that’s not true, Winston. Many people march against such things, and are appalled that Blair is still not in gaol. And I certainly feel able to criticise Israel without feeling anti-semitic. (While being glad that I don’t live in a country where all my immediate neighbouring countries have had a few goes at extinguishing an entire population.)

Edward Solomon

6th November 2019 at 11:34 am

Seeing Jeremy Corbyn’s antisemitism mapped out on a timeline like this is a worthwhile reminder of who the man really is.

https://cdn.knightlab.com/libs/timeline3/latest/embed/index.html?source=1pQcjMdd8THtTyW-uE1jta6tOWp4UhL5gFUeGu8cVMdQ&font=Default&lang=en&initial_zoom=1&height=650

Jim Lawrie

6th November 2019 at 9:51 am

“while they (the vast majority of Germans) may not actively have endorsed the Holocaust, they passively endorsed it through their inaction.”
Then “Similarly, the Parliamentary Labour Party, which is unwilling to challenge Corbyn and his cronies, is in effect endorsing the anti-Semitism in Labour’s midst.”
Mr Thompson, what a cheap, nasty, trivialisation and hijacking of the Extermination of The Jews. The inevitable result of argument by analogy, and attempts to appeal to emotion.
Name the anti-Semites in the Labour Party who by implication are endorsing something that equates to The Holocaust.
You are threatening that charge against anyone who disagrees with you. Vile. I cannot understand why Spiked have let that stand.

Jerry Owen

6th November 2019 at 9:20 am

‘But decent politicians should reject this temptation’ .. and therein lies the problem.
Swinson would cut any deal if it meant removing Brexit.. the greater good.. times have changed.. etc, and all that usual guff they come out with.
Are the EHRC still investigating the labour party?

John Millson

6th November 2019 at 8:42 am

The situation is revolting but to say Corbyn is anti-semitic is not accurate. Corbyn is publicly anti-Israel – pro Palestinian. Given the history and Britain’s connection to the Israel/Palestine situation a British PM should not take this position, just as Trump shouldn’t be backing Israel so unequivocally now.
But yes, Corbyn’s de-facto protection of anti-semites and anti-Zionists in the Labour Party makes him unfit.
No doubt many in the LP are assuming the Party will be decimated in the election meaning Corbyn will go along with his dirigiste project and slack-jawed followers. It is a risk.

Jerry Owen

6th November 2019 at 9:23 am

John Millson
I seem to remember Corbyn endorsing ..indeed defending a certain mural depicting hook nosed men sitting around a monopoly board.
Corbyn not anti semite .. pull the other one John !

Jonnie Henly

6th November 2019 at 7:46 am

“it has tolerated anti-Semitic behaviour within its ranks”

Anti Semitic behaviour within Labour has reduced since Corbyn became leader.

Stop telling blatant lies and stop using anti semitism for your own political gain.

NEIL DATSON

6th November 2019 at 8:13 am

If it is true that ‘anti semitic behaviour within Labour has reduced’ under Corbyn’s leadership it must have been truly horrendous – and extremely well hidden – before he became leader.

Jonnie Henly

6th November 2019 at 8:20 am

The media ignored it, just like they ignore antisemitism in most political parties.

It was only when dishonest politicians started using antisemitism as a stick to bash Corbyn that antisemitism in Labour got reported on. And by reported, I mean blown out of all proportion.

You can bet if Corbyn stepped down, his opponents would go back to not giving a damn about AS.

Ven Oods

6th November 2019 at 7:44 pm

“It was only when dishonest politicians started using antisemitism as a stick to bash Corbyn that antisemitism in Labour got reported on.”
It was only when all those accusations about predatory men started flying about that Harvey W got nobbled. What’s your point?

Jerry Owen

6th November 2019 at 9:25 am

Little Jonnie
‘Anti semitism has reduced under Corbyn’ ?.. so much so that the EHRC were called in, Jews left the party , and Corbyn endorsed a mural depicting hooked nosed Jews around a monopoly board.
Your posts get more detached from reality by the day.

Jerry Owen

6th November 2019 at 4:57 pm

Little Jonnie I have two posts for you as one was waiting moderation and disappeared then came back again.Still await your answer!

Jerry Owen

6th November 2019 at 2:43 pm

Little Jonnie
And the anti – semitic mural Corbyn defended.. you know the one with the hook nosed Jews huddled around a monopoly board ?
BTW waiting for your response to my previous questions !

eli Bastenbury

6th November 2019 at 4:53 pm

Under Blair/Brown Jew hatred was worse than under Corbyn, you really are dumb.

Jerry Owen

7th November 2019 at 7:56 am

Little Jonnie ..why are you running away from answering my questions ?
You keep saying you don’t run away but here you are yet again ignoring my questions.

Jonnie Henly

6th November 2019 at 7:43 am

Spiked continuing to weaponise the issue of antisemitism for their own political ends.

I’d quit lecturing others on morality if I were you.

Thomas Box

7th November 2019 at 12:57 pm

Spiked / RCP has always hated the Labour Party . Joining in with the lie of Corbyn / Labour re anti semitism is just another in a long line of smears

Jonnie Henly

6th November 2019 at 7:43 am

“Either way, Labour’s problem with Jew hatred is now beyond dispute”

It most certainly is not beyond dispute, so quit trying to shut down debate over it.

Steve Gray

6th November 2019 at 3:55 am

Labour aren’t far-left !

Lloyd Reid

6th November 2019 at 6:13 am

Current version is probably Marxist.

Dave Spart

6th November 2019 at 8:23 am

I’d say that there is a lot of ‘Left’ rhetoric, but it’s true that any remainer party must be anti working class.

Jim Lawrie

6th November 2019 at 9:25 am

Starting with The Fabian Society in 1900, middle class Labour see it as their job to correct and discipline the working class.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to comment. Log in or Register now.