The offencerati just got a book tour cancelled

Jeanine Cummins’ novel, American Dirt, has been accused of stereotyping Mexicans.

spiked

Share

Next time someone tells you ‘cancel culture’ is just a shtick people engage in on social media, point them in the direction of American Dirt. The new novel by American author Jeanine Cummins tells the story of a Mexican mother and her young son fleeing to the US border. It had already won plaudits, and was selected to be part of Oprah Winfrey’s book club, when it sparked the ire of the offencerati.

‘As a Mexican immigrant, who was undocumented, I can say with authority that this book is a harmful, stereotypical, damaging representation of our experiences’, said Mexican-American author Julissa Arce Raya: ‘Please listen to us when we tell you, this book isn’t it.’ David Bowles, a Mexican-American author and translator, similarly wrote in a Medium post that Cummins was ‘erasing authentic voices to sell an inaccurate cultural appropriation for millions’.

Author Roxane Gay also waded in: ‘It’s frustrating to see a book like this elevated by Oprah because it legitimises and normalises flawed and patronising and wrong-minded thinking about the border and those who cross it.’ Actress Salma Hayek even apologised for originally promoting the book, admitting she hadn’t actually read it.

The general message of all this is that Cummins – who is of Irish and Puerto Rican descent – has botched her depiction of Mexican immigrants, and that her publisher, Flatiron Books, was insensitive and wrong to present it as a seminal book on the subject.

Now, citing safety concerns, Flatiron has cancelled the rest of Cummins’ tour. Instead, the Guardian reports, it will be putting on ‘town-hall style events, where the author will be joined by “some of the groups who have raised objections to the book”’ – as if she has committed some great wrong and needs to make amends with those she upset.

This is crackers. People are well within their right to call American Dirt crap or stereotypical or whatever (though one suspects it’s not half as morally suspect as people are making out). But to condemn it in the way that these other authors have is ridiculous. Plus, they knew what they were doing. The aim here was not to criticise this book, but to delegitimise it. Meanwhile, the publishers should have had the courage to press on as best they could, rather than give in to mob veto.

This is all part of the ongoing battle over who can and can’t depict minority characters in art – a boneheaded discussion that has haunted the world of art and culture for years now. Those who cry ‘cultural appropriation’ at authors like Cummins for straying from their ‘lane’ are essentially trying to segment art down racial lines. This is ugly and philistine, and authors and publishers need to stand up to it.

Interestingly, Cummins seemed to see this backlash coming. At an earlier stop on her book tour, she said she ‘lived in fear of this moment, of being called to account for myself’, but that ‘in the end, the people who I met along the way, the migrants who I spoke to, the people who have put themselves in harm’s way to protect vulnerable people, they showed me what real courage looks like. They made me recognise my own cowardice.’

We would all do well to be a little braver in the face of the new book-burners.

To enquire about republishing spiked’s content, a right to reply or to request a correction, please contact the managing editor, Viv Regan.

Comments

SNJ Morgan

16th February 2020 at 11:40 am

Well Julissa & Roxanne – I just ordered my copy on Amazon (Kindle edition). Thanks for being such idiots.

Ven Oods

2nd February 2020 at 11:38 am

My favourite bit was about the lovely Salma endorsing the book without having read it.
She moved effortlessly from ‘celeb thinks her opinion matters’ to ‘wonk who endorses stuff she hasn’t encountered’.
Fine looking woman, though.

christopher birkin

2nd February 2020 at 12:52 am

The woke have essentially become a dangerous hate cult issuing a FATWA on anyone who disagrees with their extreme agenda of destroying the civilized world, be it by whipping up race and gender issues to create hate, or opposing any political idea solely with the intent to cause as much harm as possible.

Cedar Grove

31st January 2020 at 8:54 pm

Did spiked!just use the racist word “Philistine” as an insult? Oh, the horror!

Ven Oods

2nd February 2020 at 11:33 am

Weren’t the Philistines of Aegean origin? That would make them caucasian, by my reckoning. (Though they did get a bad Press, Biblically speaking.)

Ed Turnbull

31st January 2020 at 1:19 pm

Hang on a moment. Isn’t ‘American Dirt’ a work of *fiction*, not a piece of reportage on actual migrants? If so why does it matter if it’s stereotypical (isn’t *all* fiction to some extent?), and how the hell is it ‘damaging’ to Mexicans? Do those critics of this book really believe the lumpen proletariat (extremely unlikely to read this kind of ‘worthy’ literature anyway) will interpret it as an accurate depiction of the entire Mexican nation?

What next? Are those for whom taking offence seems to be a profession going to criticise Tolkein for depicting the Uruk Hai in a ‘stereotypical’ and ‘damaging’ way?

Cummins should respond to her detractors with a succinct “Get bent!”. Apologising to, or attempting to reason with, these people is futile. Their purpose is not to educate you on any actual mistakes you may have made, it’s to crush you and make you toe their party line.

SNJ Morgan

16th February 2020 at 11:54 am

They cancelled an opera because white singers dressed up as Japanese (it’s a well known one in operatic circles – just can’t remember the name). That happened a few years ago now.

Just another one of the many, many mental disorders that afflicts the Left nowadays.

Chris Dixon

30th January 2020 at 8:13 pm

Very interesting. As a completely Americanized person of Mexican decent, I am astounded at how quickly the Hispanic-American elites have converted from an assimilationist stance to a grievance-based identitarianism. Sp!ked should reach out to David Gonzalez, the creator of the Homies figures, and get his take from the perspective of someone who creates art for working class Hispanics. He was standing up to woke scolds in the Hispanic community long before it was popular.

Gee Jaybee

1st February 2020 at 11:25 am

There’s money in being offended. It is literally a profession open only to minority or “oppressed” group members.
One professional offendee even used the phrase “wrong-minded thinking” totally unironically.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to comment. Log in or Register now.