Beware the vaping fearmongers

Despite recent bad publicity, vaping is not a public-health threat.

Noel Yaxley

Topics Politics UK USA

Ewan Fisher, a teenager from Nottingham, UK, hit the headlines last month. It emerged that two years ago, when he was 17, he had suffered lung failure caused by an e-cigarette he had been using to quit smoking.

This was yet another bad news story for the vaping industry, after reports emerged in September of people dying in the US from vaping-related conditions.

Dame Sally Davies, the UK’s departing chief medical officer, certainly wasted little time in ramping up public fears over vaping, calling it a ‘ticking time bomb’. Not that she needed to make much of an effort. Public-health officials have long been busy portraying vaping as a public-health threat, with ‘no vaping’ signs now adorning many shops, restaurants, buses and train carriages. Little wonder the journal Addiction found that roughly 22 per cent of respondents believed that vaping is as bad for your health as smoking.

But how dangerous really is vaping?

Before answering, a caveat is necessary. Vaping is a relatively recent phenomenon, so longitudinal studies on the dangers of using e-cigarettes are hard to come by. But, so far at least, there appears to be very little evidence that using an e-cigarette significantly raises your chances of developing serious lung diseases, or any other long-term chronic illnesses.

In fact, according to NICE and Cancer Research UK, using e-cigarettes is at least 95 per cent less harmful to your health than tobacco smoking.

Furthermore, in 2018 there were approximately 78,000 deaths in the UK attributable to smoking. None was attributable to vaping.

In fact, vaping has actually helped between 50,000 and 70,000 people quit smoking. It has therefore potentially saved people’s lives.

But what of Ewan Fisher? It is true he nearly died after using an e-cigarette. But his lung failure was triggered by an immune response to a particular chemical used in one of the e-liquids. As such, his near-death experience was not due to vaping itself. It was an allergic reaction to a particular e-liquid.

And what of the 30-plus deaths in the US? It is reported that those who died did so of a respiratory illness, caused, so experts believe, by a form of Tetrahydrocannabinol (THC), the principal psychoactive constituent of cannabis. Crucially, as the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention have pointed out, the THC involved was obtained ‘off the street or from other informal sources’, rather than from legally sanctioned vaping providers. That is to say, the risk here comes not from vaping per se, but from using certain black-market cannabis products.

In the UK, glycerine is used in order to create the vape ‘smoke’, and propylene glycol for the throat ‘hit’ that replicates that of a tobacco cigarette. These two ingredients are not associated with the fatal respiratory illness that has taken lives in the US.

So if there is to be further regulation of the vaping industry, it needs to focus on enforcing standards for e-liquid products, and giving the public due warning as to the potential allergic reactions specific vaping products might cause. That way, the consumer can make up his or her own mind whether to use it.

We must certainly avoid stigmatising vaping. E-cigarettes actually help people give up tobacco-smoking. And, as such, they potentially save lives. It would be such a shame if they disappeared in a large cloud of overregulation and bans.

Noel Yaxley is a writer.

Picture by: Getty.

To enquire about republishing spiked’s content, a right to reply or to request a correction, please contact the managing editor, Viv Regan.


Robert Nichols

8th January 2020 at 2:33 pm

I started vaping in april 2016 thinking it might help me cut down on my tobacco use. By june 2016 i had problems breezing, i was wheezing, there was a crackling sound with each breath i took & i felt absolutely dreadful. I put it down to the vaper, so i put it to one side for a few hours and low and behold every thing cleared up. I tried the vaper yet again and all of my previous symptoms returned, i haven’t vaped since and haven’t experienced any of of the above health concerns since. 8/1/2020

Fred Shred

4th January 2020 at 1:49 pm

Noel signs off as a “writer”. In the interests of disclosure, he should have added: “and a drug addict”. Coughing Noel rips his Juul hundreds of times a day. No credible points in his shallow vapaganda piece. I’m travelling this weekend but am preparing a take-down of his silly article which I will post on Monday.

Ven Oods

5th January 2020 at 10:11 am

“but am preparing a take-down”

Am on tenterhooks, Fred.

Matt Ryan

9th January 2020 at 9:27 pm

Still waiting…

Matt Ryan

4th January 2020 at 11:52 am

Puritanical nonsense by those who like to control people’s lives. The (supposed) intelligentsia with there humanities degrees and comfortable state teat jobs love to tell the proles how they should live their lives.

Matt Ryan

4th January 2020 at 11:53 am

Sigh, no edit function. There should be their before someone with a degree in English language gets all #LearnToSpellProle on my ass.

Ven Oods

5th January 2020 at 10:09 am


Nice one, Matt.

Fred Shred

4th January 2020 at 1:53 pm

Point me to some of the puritanical nonsense you’re referring to please.

Matt Ryan

4th January 2020 at 5:20 pm

This article about the problems with vaping? Banning snacks on public transport. The minimum alcohol pricing in Jockistan. Any other “sin” taxes. That enough?

Violet Mila

4th January 2020 at 8:46 am

I am now making over $15k every month just by doing an easy job online from home using my laptop. Everybody can now get this and start making extra dollars online by just follow instructions on this website..

Stephen Kenny

3rd January 2020 at 9:28 pm

The fearmongers are the tobacco companies, who are being absolutely killed in the west. They have their own vape products, but they’ve very expensive and no good.

This was certainly the case with the absurd EU recommended regulations. The guy responsible for them left after the thing was passed, and went off to a lovely consultant job with a ‘related company’.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to comment. Log in or Register now.