Mobile version
spiked plus
About spiked
What is spiked?
Support spiked
spiked shop
Contact us
Summer school
Top issues
Arab uprisings
British politics
Child abuse panic
For Europe, Against the EU
Free speech
Jimmy Savile scandal
Parents and kids
View all issues...
special feature
The Counter-Leveson Inquiry
other sections
 Review of Books
 Monthly archive
selected authors
Duleep Allirajah
Daniel Ben-Ami
Tim Black
Jennie Bristow
Sean Collins
Dr Michael Fitzpatrick
Frank Furedi
Helene Guldberg
Patrick Hayes
Mick Hume
Rob Lyons
Brendan O’Neill
Nathalie Rothschild
James Woudhuysen
more authors...
RSS feed
a-b c-d e-h i-l m-n o-r s-u v-z index
Julian Baggini
philosopher, author, and editor of the Philosophers' Magazine

I’m somewhat surprised to find that issues surrounding the nature of truth and rationality do really seem to have emerged as politically important subjects. With religion reinvigorated and newly assertive, and scepticism of science prevalent, the question of what it is reasonable to believe, and whether some beliefs are more truthful than others, has become central. Philosophy should obviously inform this debate. However, I’m not impressed by most of what I’ve seen so far in the public arena.

It’s easy enough to attack flaky versions of relativism and irrationality (I’ve done it myself), but the positive case for rationality has failed to take its limitations seriously. If we want a ‘second enlightenment’ we need to remember just how sceptical thinkers like Hume were about the power of reason. Likewise, contemporary defenders of rationality need to acknowledge that there is much to be said for the sceptical arguments which lead others to relativism. Indeed, I would suggest that ‘relativism’ has become too much of a bogeyman. Just as there is all the difference in the world between laissez-faire capitalism and the highly regulated markets of Western Europe, so laissez-faire relativism is a different beast to many positions which ultimately deny ultimate truth. Know thine enemy.

Julian Baggini is author of books including The Pig That Wants to Be Eaten and 99 Other Thought Experiments (buy this book from Amazon (UK) or Amazon (USA)), and What’s It All About?: Philosophy and the Meaning of Life (buy this book from Amazon (UK)or Amazon (USA)). See his website.

Survey home
What we found
Survey responses
RSS feed
Anjana Ahuja
Michael Baum
Peter Cochrane
Richard Feachem
Frank Furedi
Michio Kaku
Ken MacLeod
Jonathan Meades
Munira Mirza
Matthew Parris
Ingo Potrykus
Roger Scruton
Ben Shneiderman
Lionel Shriver
Raymond Tallis
Peter Whittle
Josie Appleton
David Baulcombe
Claire Fox
William Higham
Paul Lauterbur
William Graeme Laver
Ken MacLeod
Fiona McEwen
Victor Stenger