We live longer, healthier and safer lives than
ever before. Yet society is becoming more and
more anxious about exaggerated risks, about everything
from SARS to bioterrorism to transport safety.
There has never been a more important time to
challenge the unfounded scares that hold such
sway over our society. This was the message of
Panic Attack: interrogating our obsession with
risk, a London conference organised by spiked
with the Royal
Institution of Great Britain and Tech
Central Station, Europe, on Friday 9 May.
Panic Attack brought together an international
audience from the worlds of business, government,
academia, the media and the interested public,
to discuss issues ranging from chemicals in food
to children and obesity, from Gulf War Syndrome
to global warming. Discussion of these issues
revealed the extent of society's preoccupation
with negligible levels of actual risk, and asked
why this might be.
Speakers debating these issues included Bjørn
Lomborg, author of The Skeptical Environmentalist;
Jeya Henry, professor of human nutrition at Oxford
Brookes University; Jim Bridges, chair of the
European Commission's toxicology committee; Carl
Djerassi, father of the modern contraceptive Pill;
Todd Seavey, editor of HealthFactsAndFears.com;
and Robert Nilsson, from Stockholm University.
Plenary sessions throughout the day debated
the causes and consequences of today's risk-averse
world, in which every sphere of life is organised
around the grandmotherly maxim of 'better safe
than sorry'. In business, politics, science and
culture, risk-taking is essential for progress
and innovation; and the general consensus was
that we could pay too high a price for putting
safety first.
The conference opened with Mick Hume, editor
of spiked, Jim Glassman of Tech Central
Station and Gail Cardew of the Royal Institution
outlining the themes of the day and questioning
why society has become so obsessed with risk.
In the second plenary Dr Michael Fitzpatrick,
spiked columnist and the author of The Tyranny
of Health, traced the history of panics to examine
how something like SARS can hold the world in
the grip of terror.
To conclude, the plenary titled 'The future
of risk' brought together eminent British scientist
Professor Sir Colin Berry, Frank Furedi, author
of The Culture of Fear, and Geoff Mulgan, head
of the UK government's Performance and Innovation
Unit, to discuss the consequences of risk aversion
for society now and in the future.
Panic Attack raised a number of important
questions, and pointed to ways in which our obsession
with risk could be challenged: both at the level
of getting the facts right about specific panics,
and unravelling the broader cultural assumptions
that lie behind particular scares.
While the obsession with risk shows little sign
of abating, there is a large and diverse audience
for critical voices in discussions about this
trend. The more people who are prepared to raise
their heads above the parapet, the harder it will
be for new and more destructive panics to take
hold. Panic Attack is only the beginning
of a series of events and discussions that spiked
will be initiating over the next few months.
We would like to thank everybody at the Royal
Institution, and the conference sponsors - Tech
Central Station Europe, Social Issues Research
Centre (SIRC), National Endowment for Science,
Technology and the Arts (NESTA), Luther Pendragon,
International Policy Network, Mobile Operators
Association (MOA) and Hill & Knowlton - for
making the conference such a success.
plenary
1
Panic attack
10.00
- 11.00
Why is society so obsessed with risk? Mick Hume,
editor of spiked, Jim Glassman of
Tech Central Station, and Gail Cardew of
the Royal Institution outline the themes
of the day.
Since
its inception, the contraceptive Pill has been dogged
by controversy. Fears about its safety are continually
being raised. Could irrational debates about the
risks of the Pill hold back the future development
of contraception?
Speakers:
Carl Djerassi
— father of the modern contraceptive Pill in conversation
with Ann Furedi—
formerly of the British Pregnancy Advisory Service
Chemicals are everywhere: in the dye in our clothes,
the laminating on our CDs, the preservatives in
our food. Should we be concerned about living 'toxic
lives'?
Speakers
include:
Bill
Durodié —
author of Poisonous Dummies
John Maule — director
of the Centre for Decision Research at Leeds University
Professor Jim Bridges —
chair of the European Commission's toxicity committee
Todd Seavey — editor,
HealthFactsAndFears.com chair: Josie Appleton— spiked
Is
childhood obesity on the rise - or are we over-obsessing
about our children's eating habits?
Speakers
include:
Jeya
Henry — professor
of human nutrition at Oxford Brookes University
Dr Peter Marsh —
director of the
Social Issues Research Centre
Ken Fox —
Department of Exercise, Health and Science at Bristol
University chair: Dr Michael
Fitzpatrick—
author of The Tyranny of Health
Have modern military machines lost the fighting
spirit? From Gulf War Syndrome to Intifada Syndrome,
every contemporary conflict seems to be followed
by its own sickness. Soldiers sue armies for making
them do life-threatening things, while armies themselves
sometimes seem fearful of getting stuck in on the
ground.
Speakers:
Brendan
O'Neill — assistant
editor, spiked
Simon Wessely —
professor of psychological medicine at the Institute
of Psychiatry, London chair: Jon Holbrook— barrister
Discussions about global warming tend to be polarised
around what is causing it and how we can stop it.
But couldn't we learn to live, and potentially flourish,
in a hotter climate?
Speakers
include:
Bjørn Lomborg— author,
The Skeptical Environmentalist
Sallie Baliunas—
enviro-sci host at Tech Central Station
Mark Saunders —
head of the Climate Prediction Group, University
College, London. chair: Helene Guldberg— managing editor,
spiked
Smoking causes cancer - so why, some experts ask,
does the EU continue to ban a safer alternative,
smokeless tobacco? At a time when health warnings
on cigarette packs are getting bigger and bigger,
and when smoking is increasingly frowned upon in
polite society, does it make sense to keep alternatives
like Snus off the shop shelves?
Speakers
include:
Robert Nilsson—
Stockholm University Michael Kunze
— head
of the Institute for Social Medicine, University
of Vienna Todd Seavey —
American
Council on Science
and Health
chair: Roger Bate—
International Policy Network fellow and TCS
columnist
Speakers from the worlds of science, sociology and
government examine the impact of risk aversion on
society and our lives.
Speakers:
Professor
Sir Colin Berry —
eminent British scientist
Frank Furedi —
author, The Culture of Fear
Geoff Mulgan —
head of the UK government's Performance and Innovation
Unit. chair: Derek Wanless— Trustee of the
National Endowment for Science, Technology and the
Arts