Home
Mobile version
About spiked
What is spiked?
Support spiked
spiked shop
Contact us
Advertising
Summer school
Top issues
Abortion
Arab uprisings
British politics
Economy
Environment
For Europe, Against the EU
Free speech
Nudge
Obesity
Obituaries
Occupy protests
Parents and kids
Population
The Stephen Lawrence case
USA
View all issues...

 Letters
 Review of Books
 Monthly archive
selected authors
Duleep Allirajah
Daniel Ben-Ami
Tim Black
Jennie Bristow
Sean Collins
Dr Michael Fitzpatrick
Frank Furedi
Helene Guldberg
Patrick Hayes
Mick Hume
Rob Lyons
Brendan O’Neill
Nathalie Rothschild
James Woudhuysen
more authors...
RSS feed
spiked review of books
The power of Solar
Novelist Ian McEwan is clearly not a climate-change sceptic, but as a writer he cannot resist showing up the humbug in the heavily ideological field of contemporary environmentalism.
Printer-friendly version Email-a-friend Respond

Novelist Ian McEwan’s anti-hero Michael Beard is a theoretical physicist, instinctively sceptical about the apocalyptic claims of the environmentalists preoccupied with global warming.

Beard distrusts ‘anyone who routinely referred to “the planet” as proof of thinking big’, as he resists the ‘familiar litany of shrinking glaciers, encroaching deserts, dissolving coral reefs, disrupted ocean currents, rising sea levels, disappearing this and that, on and on’. Before the book ends, though, Beard stumbles into a job as the head of a government alternative energy centre, and ends up fronting the adoption of those very technologies to sceptical investors.

Arguing with his anxious American partner Toby, Beard says: ‘Here’s the good news. The UN estimates that already a third of a million people a year are dying from climate change… Toby, listen. It’s a catastrophe. Relax!’

Reviewers have had a poke at McEwan for making fun of climate change campaigning, and in particular for a quite funny fictionalisation of an artists and intellectuals’ retreat to Spitsbergen in 2005. Having churned out thousands of tons of carbon to get there, McEwan gently mocks, the artists made a few pointless gestures against global warming. In a way, Solar is McEwan’s own artistic outcome of the Spitsbergen trip and it has caused some unhappiness that he has bitten the hand that carried him there.

“In some of the novel, McEwan reads a bit like Philip Roth or Saul Bellow, railing against the idols of the age”

The fact that reviewers have been cooler towards Solar than they were to Atonement or On Chesil Beach shows, in a way, that the campaign to alert the public to the dangers of climate change is as shrill as McEwan suggests. McEwan plainly is not a climate-change sceptic, but as a writer he cannot resist showing up the humbug in a heavily ideological field. Another criticism is that McEwan is not a great comedy writer, and it is true that it is not a laugh-out-loud book – but it is quite funny.

One of the underlying themes in Solar is of undeserved success, built on plagiarism, of individuals always on the verge of being uncovered as a sham. This rehearses one of the things that McEwan himself has been criticised for: his reliance on other people’s memoirs, like Lucilla Andrews’ nursing stories that were mined for Atonement. What McEwan does very well, for this layman’s ear anyway, is to write plausible dialogue for scientists, who are rarely fictionalised so well. Only a sentence on p150, along the lines that the City of London breeds climate sceptics, rang false to me. Having spoken in 2008 to City bankers, I can report that they were all enthusiasts for the theory of anthropogenic climate change.

There are some very funny set-piece conflicts in Solar. There is a clash between the cultural studies professor who believes that all objective reality is ‘socially constructed’ over Beard’s ill-considered speculations that, despite our best intentions, the under-representation of women in the sciences might be genetically preordained. And there is a cruel joke at the expense of Beard’s first wife, who leaves him to join a feminist commune in Wales. In these set-pieces McEwan reads a bit like Philip Roth or Saul Bellow, railing against the idols of the age. But he is a quieter writer than that, and the satire here is even-handed, far harsher on his hero’s tragic selfishness.

James Heartfield is a director of the development think-tank Audacity.org. Visit his website here.

Solar, by Ian McEwan, is published by Jonathan Cape. (Buy this book from Amazon(UK).)

Books discussed:

Solar, by Ian McEwan


March 2010
Burying Malthus to save Malthusianism
The party poopers at Darwin’s 200th birthday
It is now blasphemy to criticise Darwin
What is the point of evil?
The trials and tribulations of the ‘perfect mother’
Don’t bring back the Ministry of Food
Whatever happened to citius, altius, fortius?
A novel approach to the New Atheism
In search of the meaning behind Oz
previous issues