Mobile phones and health, information and fear
by Rob Lyons
Rob Lyons
Toxic China?
by Kirk Leech
Search for
central
politics
IT
science
liberties
risk
culture
health
life
essays
War on Iraq
Don't blow IT
Innovation
Free speech
Privacy
Work/Life
Economy

spiked-debates

(This debate is closed and is a read-only archive.)
Contributors to this debate reveal a hodgepodge of concerns
[8-Nov-2005]
According to Peter Mobley of the self-styled Wednesbury Action for the Removal of Telephone Masts, 'if any experiment is inconclusive, it follows that there's as much likelihood of a positive as there is of a negative - that is, a 50/50 chance that there's a cause for concern over harmful adverse health effects'. With such statistical insight, one presumes that Mobley fears meeting aliens on a daily basis. After all, the possible outcomes on any one day are either that you will or that you won't meet aliens, a 50/50 chance if ever there was one. Scary!

Other contributors to this spiked-debate - Catherine Gamba and Eileen O'Connor - dwell on the infantile. Gamba urges us to 'think of the children'. I encourage her to watch the Simpsons episode 'Much Apu About Nothing', where the same phrase is repeated systematically throughout.

Numerous other contributors reveal a hodgepodge of concerns relating to trust, independence, toxic food, environmental chemicals, the kitchen sink, Old Uncle Tom Cobley and all. What is their point, exactly? Or is it better to have lots of points, just in case? After all, according to this logic, having lots of points must improve their odds of being right.

Bill Durodié, researcher, UK

View archived list of responses

Debate home
The debate
Mike Dolan
Mobile Operators Association
Adam Burgess
author, Cellular Phones, Public Fears, and a Culture of Precaution
Alan Meyer
Mast Action UK
Jack Rowley
GSM Association
Stuart McWilliam
journalist
View the list of responses

Useful resources
The Stewart Report: Summary and Recommendations,
May 2000 [pdf]

Can mobile phones damage your health?
O2 [pdf]

Health and mobile safety
O2

Radiation Protection Division
UK Health Protection Agency

Mobile Telecommunications and Health Research Programme (MTHR)

Electromagnetic fields
World Health Organisation

O2 corporate responsibility report 2005

Mobile Operators Association


Corrections Terms & Conditions spiked, Signet House, 49-51 Farringdon Road, London, EC1M 3JP
Email:
email spiked © spiked 2000-2006 All rights reserved.
spiked is not responsible for the content of any third-party websites.